Write descriptions students can check

Replace broad judgments with evidence a student can point to in their work.

Too broad

Explain your results clearly.

Specific evidence

State which material absorbed more water and use your measurements to explain the difference.

Name what the work needs to show

“Clear,” “detailed” and “effective” can describe a judgment without explaining it. Say which details matter and what those details need to do.

Keep the same skill across the row

If Meeting asks students to support a claim with measurements, the other levels should describe how well they connect the claim and measurements. Adding more pages is a different requirement.

Give each Look for one job

A row about explaining results should not also assess neatness, effort and spelling. Separate those ideas if they are part of the intended learning.

Check it against a piece of work

Ask whether two teachers could point to the same evidence when using the description. If they would have to guess what you meant, revise the wording.

Check the AI draft

Read the result against your assignment and students. Edit a description that asks for the wrong thing, then check that the levels still describe the same skill.

See the science example